SusieJ's Advent Calendar December 10, 2012

Hank Stuever: Tinsel: A Search for America's Christmas Present

From 4,000 years ago, we find ourselves in the present, in Plano, Texas.

Stuever is a reporter for the Washington Post; he spent Christmas before the Great Recession in Texas interviewing, shadowing, and alnost living with a number of residents to learn how they celebrated Christmas.

The choice of Texas was inspired. I often think Texas is to the US what Bavaria is to Germany: big, thinks of itself as semi-indepedent, and the source of almost all stereotypes about the country.

If you are looking for insight to be handed to you about modern Christmas in perhaps the most-Christmas-obsessed nation, you won't find it here. Stuever is a reporter, a chronicler, not an interperter, which is perhaps for the best.

Stuever describes the Christmas celebrations of three families: Jeff Trykoski, whose videos of his home-grown Christmas light show led to designing the local municipal show; Tammie Parnell, whose love of decorating at Christmas led to a side business decorating the homes of people without the time or inclination for decorating; and Carol Cavazos, member of a prosperity-gospel megachurch. By examining how they celebrate Christmas, Stuever shows how they, and many Americans, find and give meaning to the holiday.

Because American Christmas is stretched over such a long period — for Parnell and Trykoski the planning and buying last all year long, but even for the less Christmas-obsessed it starts well before Thanksgiving — this is not the simple and deeply-moving holiday of Bob Cratchit and Tiny Tim. It's complex, and ambivalent, often not quite up to expectations, and yet with some good if not perfect moments.