SusieJ's Advent Calendar December 8, 2009

Confession: Old Spice

When a cookbook author writes a how-to tome, somewhere in the middle or towards the end, after the importance of measuring properly, there will be a admonition to use only the freshest of herbs and spices, to buy from a reputable spice merchant with high turn-over, and to throw out anything over a year old. Having baked with really fresh spices, I nod my head and say, yes, yes, everything does taste better when the spices are fresh and zingy and don't taste like cardboard.

But throw out anything over a year old? Does your grandmother know you're suggesting that?

I dare anyone to use even the smallest jar of ground cloves in a year.

So, some of the ground spices in my cabinet are five years old. Some of the herbs are even older (and those are stored next to the stove — the horror!). Oh, sure, I'll grind whole spices as needed — but that's only because I'm crazy about baking. No one just getting into baking will keep whole spices and a spice grinder and containers for the ground spices. And where would you put all of it?

[Christmas at the Chestnut Hill branch of spice super-store Penzey's.]